AMERICAN
ACADEMY
OF PEDIATRICS
Committee on School
Health
Committee on Injury and Poison Prevention
"School Bus Transportation
of Children With Special Needs"
Many
school-aged children with handicaps are transported in school
buses. A recent amendment to the Individuals with Disabilities
Education Act has established requirements for infants and toddlers
to have access todevelopmental and rehabilitation facilities.
This amendment, to Part H of the Individuals with Disabitilites
Education Act (enacted as part of Public Law 102-119), however,
does not specify how these children are to be transported to these
facilities, a responsibility that will be faced by many school
systems.
FMVSS 222 (School
Bus Passenger Seaating and Crash Protection) established safety
requirements for school bus interiors, but to date it only applied
to ablebodied children. However, an amendment to FMVSS 222 becomes
effective in January 1994 that applies to the securement of wheelchairs
and their occupants in school buses. National recommended standards
for special education school buses were revised in May 1990 by
the Eleventh National Standards Conference on School Transportation.
Wheelchairs are
the primary mode of transport on the school bus for many children
with special needs. They have not been developed as safety restraint
devices, however, and are not currently subjected to any crash-testing
requirements. Research, (2-5) nevertheless, has pro- vided a basis
for recommendations concerning occupant securement for a wheelchair-dependent
child and a child with special needs who is transported on a school
bus:
1. Any child who can assist with
transfer or be "reasonably" moved from a wheelchair, stroller,
or special seating device to the original manufacurer's forward-facing
vehicle seat equipped with dynamically tested occupant restraints
or be "reasonably" moved to a child car seat complying with FMVSS
213 requirement should be so transferred for transportation to
and from school. The unoccupied wheelchair also should be secured
adequately in the vehicle(6) to prevent it from becoming a dangerous
projectile in the event of a sudden stop or crash.
2. Passenger seats that have a
child safety seat or restraint system attached thereto should
have a reinforced frame and meet the requirements of FMVSS 208
(occupant crash protection), FMVSS 209 (seat belt assemblies),
and FMVSS 210 (seat belt anchorages).
3. All child safety seats or restraint
systems used for trans- portation in any school bus by children
who weigh less than 50 lb should meet the requirements of FMVSS
213.
4. Child safety seats or restraint
systems must be secured to the bus seat in a manner prescribed
and approved by the manufacturer.
5. Car safety seats used to transport
children weighing less than 20 lb should be attached to the
school bus seat in a rearward- facing position.
6. Occupied wheelchair(s) should
be secured in a forward- facing position.
7. Three-wheeled, cart-type units
and other wheelchair/ stroller-type devices should not be permitted
for occupied transport in a school bus unless results of impact
tests demonstrate their ability to be secured under impact loading
conditions. Any wheel- chair or stroller-type unit designed
and approved by a manufacturer for transportation must be used
according to manufacturer's instructions.
8. Wheelchairs should be secured
with fastening devices that are attached to the floor. Fastening
devices should attach to the wheelchair at four points and must
have demonstrated capabilities for restraining the wheelchair
during frontal impact with force conditions of 30 mph and 20g.
The wheelchair securement system must not apply restraint to
the wheelchair through the occupant and should attach to the
frame of the wheelchair rather than to the wheels.
9. Any occupied wheelchairs should
be secured with four- point tie-down devices. These tie-down
systems should be dynamically tested with a male dummy at the
50th percentile or with a dummy at the appropriate size for
the type of wheelchair necessary.
10. Lap boards or metal or plastic
trays attached to the wheelchair or to adaptive equipment should
be removed and secured separately for transport.
11. An occupant restraint system
that has been tested at 30 mph and 20g force conditions and
that includes upper torso restraint (ie, shoulder harness) and
lower torso restraint (ie, lap belt over pelvis) should be provided
for each wheelchair-seated occupant.
12. Any liquid oxygen transported
in a school bus should be securely mounted and fastened to prevent
damage and exposure to intense heat.
The
following considerations should be incorporated into the school
system planning for the transportation requirements of children
with special needs.
1. In accordance with state laws
and regulations, a nurse or an aide with appropriate medical training
can provide necessary on- board assistance and support to most
children with tracheostomies who may require suctioning or emergency
care during school bus transport. School systems should consider
providing nurses or aides, when medically necessary, to help reduce
the potential for respiratory and other related problems occurring
while the children are on the school bus. This assistance should
be included where appropriate in the child's Individual Education
Plan.
2. School bus transportation staff
should have annual access to training programs and resource
material in special needs trans- portation to ensure that they
can provide the most current and proper support to children
with special transportation requirements. Trans- portation staff
who work with children with special needs can carry out their
daily responsibilities when provided with documented training
that assures consistent and proper restraint for children with
special needs on school buses.(7)
3. Parents of children with special
needs should be informed of the importance of incorporating
appropriate and safe transportation specifications in their
child's individual education plan.
4. School systems can help assure
optimum protection for children with special needs during school
bus transport by establishing a written plan that outlines procedures
for emergency evacuation and by requiring, at the minimum, an
evacuation drill for each school year that enables the transportation
staff to practice working with evacuating children under their
care.
5. Children who are technology-supported
may have an increased potential for carrying infectious and
communicable diseases. Schools are advised to develop a comprehensive
infection control program to protect transportation staff, school
employees, and the children being transported. Caretakers who
have direct contact with at-risk populations of children should
be offered hepatitis B vaccine. Transportation staff should
be provided with training and supplies that prepare them to
carry out universal precaution practices and procedures to control
unnecessary exposure to various diseases.(8)
The
American Academy of Pediatrics anticipates that more states will
begin to address the transportation requirements of children with
special needs. Pediatricians can help their patients by being aware
of general guidelines for evaluating restraint systems that meet
the needs of children with special needs and remaining informed
of new resources as they become available. Periodically updated
information on specific restraint systems for children with special
needs can be obtained through the American Academy of Pediatrics.
In addition, pediatricians can play important roles at the local
and state levels to assist in the evaluation and development of
school bus specifications that are responsive to the safe transportation
requirements of children with special needs.
Committee on Injury and Poison
Prevention, 1993 to 1994
William E. Boyle, Jr, MD, Chair
Marilyn J. Bull, MD
Murray L. Katcher, MD, PhD
S. Donald Palmer, MD
George C. Rodgers, Jr, MD, PhD
Barbara L. Smith, MD
Joseph J. Tepas III, MD
Liaison Representatives:
Jean Athey, PhD, Maternal and Child Health Bureau
Katherine Kaufer Christoffel, MD, MPH, General and Emerg. Pediatrics
Peter Scheidt, MD, MPH, National Institute of Child Health and
Human Development
Richard A. Schieber, MD, Centers for Disease Control
Milton Tenebein, MD, Canadian Pediatric Society
Section Liaisons:
James Griffith, MD, Section on Injury and Poison Prevention
Susan B. Tully, MD, Section on Pediatric Emergency Medicine
Designated Representative:
Deborah Tinsworth, US Consumer Product Safety Commission
REFERENCES
1. National Standards for School
Buses and National Standards for School Bus Operations. Revised
Ed. Chicago, IL: National Safety Cncl 1990.
2. Schneider LW. Protection for
the severly disabled: a new challenge in occupant restraint.
Proceedings of the International Symposium on Occupant Restraint.
Morton Grove, IL: American Association for Automotive Medicine
1981:217-231.
3. Schneider LW, Melvin JW, Cooney
CE. Impact Sled Test Evaluation of Restraint Systems Used in
Transportation of Handicapped Children. Warren- dale, PA:
Society of Automotive Engineers; 1979. Technical Paper 790074.
4. National Standard for School
Bus Operation: Special Education. Pre- sented at Eleventh
National Standards Conference on School Transportation May 1990;
Tacoma WA.
5. Wheelchair occupant restraint
assemblies for use in motor vehicles. Australian Standard
2:942-1987. North Sydney, Australia: The Standards Association
of Australia; 1987.
6. 575 IAC (Indiana Code) 1-5.5
Vehicles for Transporting the Handicapped February 1990.
7. Stephens LL, Beekman LE, Munk
LG, Stefans VA. Study of Transportation of Medically Fragile
Children. Core Curriculum for Special Education Transportation
Health Care. Special Education Services, Michigan Dept. of Education;
April 1989; vol 4.
8. Stephens LL, Beckman LE, Munk
LG, Stefans VA. Study of Transportation of Medically Fragile
Children. Personnel Qualifications Training Related Transportation
Issues. Special Education Services, Michigan Department of Education,
April 1989: vol 3.
|