Support or Propose
Organizations
with Announced Positions
About Seat Belts on Large School Buses
Last updated Dec. 5, 2005
Proponents:
Many
organizations believe that seat belts should be required on large
school buses to maximize occupant protection. Among the organizations
advocating the installation of seat belts in school buses with
GVWRs greater than 10,000 lb., and the year in which they adopted
the position, are the following:
- State
of Florida, 1999
- State
of Louisiana, 1999
- State
of California, 1999
- American
Academy of Pediatrics, 1984
- American
Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, 1992
- American
College of Emergency Physicians, 1987
- American
Medical Association, 1987
- Cable
News Network (CNN), 1998
- Clarkstown
Parent Teacher Association, 1988
- Great
Britain, 1998
- National
Coalition for Seatbelts on School Buses (NCSSB)
- National
Parent Teacher Association (PTA), 1985, 1998
- New
Jersey Institute of Technology, 1989
- People Advocating Seat Belt
Safety
- Physicians
for Automotive Safety, 1980
- Society
for Adolescent Medicine, 1985
- State
of New Jersey, 1992
- State
of New York, 1987
Opponents:
Meanwhile,
many other organizations believe that large school buses should
not be equipped with seat belts to maximize occupant protection.
Among the organizations opposing the installation of 2-point,
lap-belt seat belts in school buses with GVWRs greater than
10,000 lb., and the year in which they adopted the position,
are the following:
- 10th
National Conference on School Transportation, 1985
- Florida
Dept. of Education, Pupil Transportation Unit, 1997
- National
Academy of Sciences, Transportation Research Board, 1989
- National
Association for Pupil Transportation
- National
Association of State Directors of Pupil Transportation Services (NASDPTS),
1995 *
- National
Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), 1997 **
- National
Safety Council, 1986
- National
School Transportation Association, 1984
- National
Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) ***
- New
Hampshire School Transportation Association
- New
York Association for Pupil Transportation
- Ontario
School Bus Operators Association, 1995
- Province
of Ontario Ministry of Transportation
- Student
Transportation Association of Massachusetts
- Transport
Canada
* For lap/shoulder belts, NASDPTS said in 2002 that it was concerned seating capacity could be adversely affected, as could school bus joint strength. But if funding were made available to implement lap/shoulder belts in school buses, the state directors would support the initiative.
** Advocates three-point lap/shoulder belts as a safer alternative to two-point lap belts and as an additional safety measure to school bus compartmentalization.
*** Since 1999 the NTSB's official position on lap/shoulder belts on school buses is that they exhibit safety benefits above and beyond compartmentalization and that they should be considered.
|